Report · November 12, 2026
Which deposit state makes the return easier?
People want two things: a return spot close by, and a deposit that actually comes back. No state wins on every number we already have. This page lines those numbers up. It is our comparison, not a state study.
What we found
- New York has the shortest typical trip: 0.4 miles in a straight line. 74.4% of people there live within 1 mile of a listed spot.
- Iowa has the longest typical trip: 3.3 miles. We list only redemption centers approved by the Iowa DNR. Some grocery stores still take returns, so real access may be better than shown.
- Connecticut has a desert share of 0% in the October 21, 2026 report. A desert means more than 10 miles, or more than 3 miles in a crowded area.
- Massachusetts is close for most people (typical trip 0.8 miles, desert share 0.1%). Its redemption rate was 35% in 2024. That is the lowest number in this set. The rates are not all the same kind of measure.
- Oregon has the highest number in the set: 90.4% (redemption rate (preliminary), 2024).
- If you divide unclaimed deposits by the 2020 population, the estimate is $19.04 per person in Iowa and $3.22 in Maine. The deposit year and the population year are not the same, so this is an estimate. A bigger dollar total is not the same thing as a harder return, because the states are different sizes.
The mile numbers and the cited rates come from the Redemption Deserts report (October 21, 2026). We did not collect new state figures for this page.
Typical trip
Shorter means more people live close to a listed return spot. The number is the median straight-line distance. Half of people live closer, and half live farther. Roads make the real trip longer.
People within 1 mile
This is the share of people who live within 1 straight-line mile of a listed spot.
Cited return rate
A longer bar is a higher rate. Read the label. These rates are not all counted the same way, and the years are not all the same. Do not treat the order as an official ranking.
The numbers
| State | Typical trip | Within 1 mile | Desert share | Return rate | Unclaimed deposits | Per person (estimate) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York | 0.4 mi | 74.4% | 0.8% | 68.6% redemption rate, 2024 | $151.4 million (2023) | $7.49 |
| Massachusetts | 0.8 mi | 60.7% | 0.1% | 35% redemption rate, 2024 | $71.7 million (2023) | $10.21 |
| Connecticut | 0.9 mi | 54.2% | 0% | 64.5% redemption rate, 2024 | $46.7 million (2024 (four quarters ending Dec 31)) | $12.95 |
| Michigan | 1 mi | 48.1% | 1.6% | 69.4% share of deposits refunded, 2025 | $119.2 million (2025) | $11.83 |
| Oregon | 1.2 mi | 42.8% | 3.3% | 90.4% redemption rate (preliminary), 2024 | $21.8 million (2023) | $5.14 |
| California | 1.3 mi | 38.4% | 9.7% | 70% recycling rate, 2024 | $400.2 million (2023) | $10.12 |
| Vermont | 1.4 mi | 39.9% | 1.3% | 69.6% redemption rate, 2024 | $3.6 million (2023) | $5.65 |
| Hawaii | 1.5 mi | 34.5% | 7.9% | 51.8% redemption rate, FY 2025 | $20.8 million (FY 2024) | $14.30 |
| Maine | 1.9 mi | 28.4% | 2.6% | 74% redemption rate, 2024 | $4.4 million (2024) | $3.22 |
| Iowa | 3.3 mi | 14.4% | 24.1% | 49% recovery rate (includes curbside recycling, not only deposit returns), 2022 | $60.8 million (2021) | $19.04 |
Unclaimed deposits per person
Estimate: unclaimed deposits for the year in the table, divided by the 2020 Census population. 91,340,996 people live in these 10 states in that census. The deposit years run from 2021 to 2025, so this is not a same-year rate.
How we did this
We did not measure new miles. The distance numbers are the October 21, 2026 Redemption Deserts results. That work used 2020 Census population centers and our return lists, in a straight line. A desert is more than 10 miles, or more than 3 miles where there are 3,000 people or more per square mile.
The return rates and unclaimed deposits are the figures already cited on that report, with the same years and the same sources. The per-person estimate is those unclaimed dollars divided by the 2020 state population, rounded to the cent.
Limits
- California (high). The list is the full CalRecycle list of certified recycling centers. Few stores take returns in California, so this is close to complete. Return rate: 70% recycling rate, 2024.
- Connecticut (medium). We list grocery stores because the law says they must take returns. Some may not, so real access may be worse than shown. Return rate: 64.5% redemption rate, 2024.
- Hawaii (high). The list is the full Hawaii Department of Health list of certified redemption centers. Most stores do not take returns. Return rate: 51.8% redemption rate, FY 2025.
- Iowa (low). We list only redemption centers approved by the Iowa DNR. Some grocery stores still take returns, so real access may be better than shown. Return rate: 49% recovery rate (includes curbside recycling, not only deposit returns), 2022.
- Maine (medium). We use the Maine DEP list of licensed redemption centers (as of 10/20/2026) and the CLYNK bag drops. Some big stores also take returns, and we do not list them. So real access may be a little better than shown. Return rate: 74% redemption rate, 2024.
- Massachusetts (medium). We list grocery stores and big stores because the law says they must take returns. Some may not, so real access may be worse than shown. Return rate: 35% redemption rate, 2024.
- Michigan (medium). We list grocery stores because the law says they must take returns. Some may not, so real access may be worse than shown. Return rate: 69.4% share of deposits refunded, 2025.
- New York (medium). We list grocery stores because the law says they must take returns. Some may not, so real access may be worse than shown. Return rate: 68.6% redemption rate, 2024.
- Oregon (medium). We list BottleDrop centers and the stores and drop sites BottleDrop lists. Some other stores may also take returns, so real access may be better than shown. Return rate: 90.4% redemption rate (preliminary), 2024.
- Vermont (medium). We list grocery stores that are not on the state list of excused stores. Some may not take returns, so real access may be worse than shown. Return rate: 69.6% redemption rate, 2024.
On November 12, 2026 the live lists for a few states had a slightly different spot count than the October 21 report. We did not rerun the mile math. The Redemption Deserts report says which states changed.
Sources
- New York: NYS DEC, via Container Recycling Institute Bottle Bill Resource Guide; NWRA Bottle Bill Escheats Summary Report (Dec 2025), Table 1, from NYS fiscal year tax collections
- Massachusetts: Container Recycling Institute, Bottle Bill Resource Guide; NWRA Bottle Bill Escheats Summary Report (Dec 2025), Table 8, from Massachusetts Dept. of Revenue annual reports
- Connecticut: CT DEEP, same slides (rolling four-quarter rate, calendar year 2024); CT DEEP, Bottle Bill Advisory Group meeting slides (Apr 2026), estimated escheats
- Michigan: Michigan Dept. of Treasury, Bottle Deposit Information; Michigan Dept. of Treasury, Bottle Deposit Information (total owed by under-redeemers)
- Oregon: Oregon Beverage Recycling Cooperative, 2024 Annual Report; NWRA Bottle Bill Escheats Summary Report (Dec 2025), Table 1
- California: CalRecycle, Biannual Report of Beverage Container Sales, Returns, Redemption, and Recycling Rates (calendar year 2024); NWRA Bottle Bill Escheats Summary Report (Dec 2025), Table 1, compiled from CalRecycle data
- Vermont: Container Recycling Institute, Bottle Bill Resource Guide; NWRA Bottle Bill Escheats Summary Report (Dec 2025), Table 10, from Vermont Dept. of Taxes
- Hawaii: Hawaii DOH Office of Solid Waste Management, Annual Report to the 2026 Legislature; Hawaii State Auditor, Financial and Program Audit of the DOH Deposit Beverage Container Program, June 30, 2024 (Report 25-08)
- Maine: Container Recycling Institute, as reported in NWRA report Table 2; NWRA Bottle Bill Escheats Summary Report (Dec 2025), Table 7, from Maine Revenue Services
- Iowa: Iowa DNR, 2022 Recovery Rate Report for Deposit Beverage Containers (May 2024); NWRA Bottle Bill Escheats Summary Report (Dec 2025), Table 1 (from data gathered by GT Environmental)
- Distances and population: Redemption Deserts report, October 21, 2026, using 2020 Census population centers.